Top Credentialing Mistakes and How to Prevent Them: A Practical Guide for Practice Administrators
Credentialing might seem like a never-ending checklist—a task no one’s thrilled to tackle but everyone relies on. Yet getting credentialing right can mean the difference between smooth, steady reimbursements and a backlog of issues that derail the practice’s growth. To make credentialing a strength rather than a headache, we’ve put together a guide to the common mistakes that hold up the process and how you can avoid them.
1. Incomplete Applications: The Classic Roadblock
the mistake
Missing even a single detail or document in an application is a surefire way to stall the process. Incomplete applications often mean a long back-and-forth with payers, and a delay in approval that ripples through your billing and operations.
How to Avoid It
Treat credentialing like a checklist. Make sure each application is complete, with every field filled and each document attached, before sending it off. The clearer and more comprehensive the application, the fewer follow-up requests you’ll receive and the faster approvals will come through. Don't forget how powerful a second pair of eyes can be! Having a second person review your work to spot any missing entries or typos can be a great way to spot small mistakes that could cause big delays.
2. Missing Documents: A Small Miss with a Big Impact
the mistake
Forgetting essential documents—like the DEA license, malpractice insurance, or updated state license—can stop credentialing in its tracks. These documents are crucial for payers to verify qualifications, and missing even one can halt the process indefinitely
How to Avoid It
Keep a secure, organized library for each provider’s essential documents, regularly updated with new expiration dates. A digital project management tool or shared drive can be handy here, especially one with folder management to keep things tidy. This way, all documents are readily available for applications, and no one’s scrambling to find the right files when it’s time to submit.
3. Failure to Track Expiration Dates: Lapses That Lead to Losses
the mistake
Licenses, malpractice insurance, and other credentials aren’t permanent; they need periodic renewals. Letting these expire not only disrupts credentialing but also prevents providers from billing or even seeing patients until the renewal is complete.
How to Avoid It
Set up reminders well in advance of expiration dates—think 60 or 90 days before the renewal is due. Whether you prefer a calendar alert, a reminder in your email, or a project management tool like ClickUp (our tool of choice), having automated prompts keeps you ahead of renewals and ensures that credentialing never gets derailed by an overlooked date.
4. Ignoring Primary Source Verification: Missing a Critical Step
the mistake
Primary source verification is how payers confirm a provider’s licensure, education, and certifications. Without it, your credentialing application can hit a wall. Applications missing this essential step are prone to rejection, slowing the whole process.
How to Avoid It
Before you send an application to a payer, verify credentials directly from the source. Think of it as a pre-check: whether you’re using public records or a verification service, confirming these details early on ensures accuracy and keeps the process moving.
5. Not Responding to Payer Inquiries Promptly: When Silence Leads to Stalls
the mistake
Credentialing doesn’t stop once the application is sent; payers often follow up with questions or additional requests. Failing to respond quickly to these inquiries can leave your application in limbo.
How to Avoid It
Designate a point person to monitor payer communications daily. If your team has a shared inbox or task board, use it to log each inquiry and set reminders for responses. Quick follow-ups keep the process on track and show payers you’re organized and responsive.
6. Outdated CAQH Profiles: An Overlooked Detail with Major Impact
the mistake
Many payers rely on CAQH profiles to verify provider information, and an outdated profile can lead to delays or denials. Without accurate data, you risk unnecessary complications in the credentialing process.
How to Avoid It
Make it a habit to review each provider’s CAQH profile quarterly. A simple reminder on your task list—whether digital or on a planner—is enough to stay ahead. Keeping profiles current is a small step that keeps the credentialing process seamless.
7. Ignoring Payer-Specific Requirements: Because Not All Paths Are the Same
the mistake
Each payer has unique requirements, and overlooking these distinctions can lead to delays. Failing to meet each payer’s specifics—like missing forms or incorrect formats—complicates and prolongs credentialing.
How to Avoid It
Develop checklists tailored to each payer, noting any unique forms, requirements, or fees. Even a spreadsheet works, but if you’re looking for something more dynamic, a project management tool can help track each payer’s details individually. By tailoring the application process, you avoid unnecessary delays and get approvals faster.
8. Not Following Up: Don’t Let Applications Drift Out of Sight
the mistake
Once submitted, applications can sometimes sit unnoticed in the payer’s queue. Without regular follow-ups, they can fall through the cracks, delaying approvals.
How to Avoid It
Schedule follow-ups every two weeks to check on the status of pending applications. A set routine—whether it’s an email reminder or a recurring task in your project management tool—ensures you catch any snags before they become significant setbacks.
Building a Strong Credentialing System
Credentialing doesn’t have to be a source of stress. With a little organization and the right tools, the process can support your practice’s stability and growth.
At Wayfinder, we use ClickUp to keep everything organized, from checklists to reminders, because we’ve found it’s a system that works. Whatever tool you choose, make sure it’s reliable and fits your team’s workflow, so credentialing becomes a steady process you can count on.
With these strategies in place, credentialing becomes less about scrambling to meet requirements and more about setting a strong, organized foundation that supports the practice at every turn.
